Christian Munthe
Gothenburg University
Go here for a look the transparents used for this presentation
ABSTRACT
The IOC and WADA have announced their ambition to develop control program
in order to detect athletes' illegitimate use of genetic technology for
enhancing performance. Although it is far from clear what such uses should
be counted as illegitimate, as well as to what extent the idea of control
programs for such things is a feasible idea, I will assume that such programs
will concern so-called somatic genetic modifications that aims at altering
the athlete's initial bodily biochemistry in a way that may enhance performance
without the presence of any medical reason for undertaking such modifications.
This means that the envisioned control-program will have to make use of
the method of genetic testing in order to detect the possible presence
(or non-presence) of various genetic variants within the athlete. As a
consequence of this, several ethical issues familiar within the field of
genetic testing for health purposes are suddenly actualised within the
area of doping control. These issues concern primarily how to handle and
communicate the information about the athlete that is uncovered by such
testing. However, due to the ways in which gene doping may be performed,
in the case of atheletic control programs, issues of medical safety and
the question of what hardships it is reasonable to require of athletes
to endure also become paramount. As a consequence, one may ask whether
or not sporting ethics will have to consider applying the rule of informed
consent in connection to testing programs of the kind here discussed.